See Full HTML Site

Muslim-Americans can celebrate Ramadan while mourning Sept. 11

By Omar Ghabra

Published: Tuesday, September 7, 2010

Updated: Wednesday, September 8, 2010

Mosque

AP

Protestors rally against a proposed Islamic center and mosque near ground zero in New York.

Muslims all over the world mark the end of the month of Ramadan with a celebration called Eid-al-Fitr. During this month, Muslims refrain from eating, drinking and any form of sexual activity from dawn until dusk.

They view it as a time for reflection, patience, community and charity. Ramadan is the ninth month of the Islamic calendar, which is based on the lunar calendar.

The lunar year is typically 10 to 12 days shorter than the 365 day Gregorian year. This means that each year, Ramadan begins about 10 days earlier than the year before. Last year, Ramadan began on Aug. 22 and ended Sept. 1.

This year, Ramadan began Aug. 11 and will end Sept. 9. Eid-al-Fitr will be celebrated on Sept. 10, one day before the ninth anniversary of the Sept. 11 attacks.

This has proven to be an unfortunate coincidence for American Muslims who have been thrust on the defensive for the past several months as rising anti-Islamic sentiment stemming from the outrage over the proposed Park 51 complex near ground zero has become a national political issue.

In an election season where politicians on both sides of the aisle are desperately clamoring to score cheap political points, Islam in America has become one of the most controversial issues.

This debate, like most in modern politics, has been plagued by misinformation and a troubling detachment from facts or reason.

In recent days, it's further escalated as a number of incidents have demonstrated what happens when politicians and political talk show hosts sow hostility and fear of "the other" for short-term political gains.

A Muslim cab driver in New York, Ahmed Sharif, was stabbed multiple times by his passenger Aug. 24 after the passenger asked him if he was a Muslim. The next day Sharif told a journalist that "before yesterday, I never felt like I didn't belong here."

In another incident, a drunken man entered a mosque in Queens shouting "terrorists" as he proceeded to urinate in the area where people were praying. Most recently, federal authorities in Tennessee have determined that a fire at a mosque that is under construction was arson.

It is in this dangerous climate that Muslim communities all over the country find themselves as they prepare to celebrate the end of their holy month.

Many of these communities, including the one right here in Morgantown, are taking special precautions due to the fear of being harassed or worse.

They fear people will mistake the timing of the celebration of Eid with the anniversary of Sept. 11 and further inflame the bigoted sentiments that have rapidly grown in recent months.

According to Sohail Chaudhry, imam of the Islamic Center of Morgantown, this year's Eid prayer service was originally planned to be held outdoors, but security concerns prompted them to move it indoors.

Additionally, a community dinner was moved from Saturday to Sunday to avoid any confusion regarding the motives behind the celebration. Chaudhry also mentioned that the WVU Police Department was notified of these events and will be providing security for them.

It's a sad day in this country when a minority group has to ask for police protection just to practice their faith.

Many signs indicate this could just be the beginning.

According to a recent poll conducted by TIME Magazine, only 55 percent of Americans would approve of a mosque being built in their community. This growing animosity is undoubtedly linked to the inflammatory rhetoric being spewed by right wing politicians on a daily basis.

They create an environment that is becoming increasingly conducive to violence and they are showing no signs of stopping. Sept. 11 will be marked with a number of Islamophobic gatherings this year.

These events range from Pastor Terry Jones' "Burn a Quran Day" to the anti-Islam rally at ground zero featuring former UN ambassador John Bolton and the Dutch fascist parliamentarian Geert Wilders, who advocates banning all mosques from being built and wants to stop all Muslim immigration to his country.

Many of these people tend to propagate their ignorant beliefs based on the false notion that America was founded as a "Christian nation." Thus people from a Judeo-Christian background are more "American" than Muslims or people who aren't religious at all.

This, of course, could not be further from the truth.

To say that this is somehow a "Christian nation" is to re-write history. The following, taken from a treaty signed by none other than John Adams, explicitly refutes this distortion: "the government of the United States is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion ... The United States is not a Christian nation any more than it is a Jewish or a Mohammedan (Muslim) nation."

It couldn't be any clearer.

Being American has nothing to do with one's religious beliefs. Being American is about acknowledging the rights of all people, including those we disagree with. Anyone who tries to stir up fear and hatred of another group they disagree with is un-American.

But with their hateful rhetoric, they are endangering the lives of innocent people and spitting on the freedoms so many have fought to protect.

Despite the intimidation and fear mongering, Muslims will celebrate their holiday later this week. And on Saturday, they will mourn the tragedy of Sept. 11 with millions of their American brothers and sisters.

Those who seek to benefit from the divisions they are creating in our society will come up empty-handed because they are on the wrong side of history. America is and always will be a pluralistic society, where people of all faiths are welcome.

If you have a problem with that, then you have a problem with the ideals this country was founded upon.

Comments

13 comments
Muslim
Wed Sep 29 2010 01:35
Ramadan is not a celebration, it's a month.
Anonymous
Sun Sep 26 2010 01:05
Muslms...
Anonymous
Fri Sep 10 2010 14:56
No, Muslims cannot celebrate Ramadan while mourning Sept 11. They aren't at the same bleeding time. Ramadan is over as of sundown last night. September 11 starts at midnight. Two times cannot occur at once.
Moreover, Ramadan is a time of preparing oneself for Eid, a day actually celebrated. Ramadan is not a month of celebration.
Anonymous
Thu Sep 9 2010 02:07
"...Is it not that the Declaration of Independence first organized the social compact on the foundation of the Redeemer’s mission upon earth? That it laid the cornerstone of human government upon the first precepts of Christianity?" - John Quincy Adams....I guess the apple fell a bit from the tree...his son doth disagree
Anonymous
Thu Sep 9 2010 02:01
Am I the only one who saw the hate crime statistics which showed that Jews were 7 times more likely than Muslims to be subjecting to violence based on prejudice in 2009. In addition, if you include both Protestants and Catholics, then Christians too, are more likely than Muslims to experience prejudicial violence. Get over it.
Anonymous
Wed Sep 8 2010 22:44
"Are you high, or just an idiot?"

I think that proves the point. He's saying it is idiotic to condemn an entire group of people because one of them is an idiot.

Anonymous
Wed Sep 8 2010 16:31
"So I guess every service Jeremiah Wright led was an anti-American rally, making Obama anti-American??"

Are you high, or just an idiot?

Conservative who isn't a bigot
Wed Sep 8 2010 14:10
No, but the people that oppose the mosque at ground zero generally oppose mosques anywhere in the US, so yeah it will be an anti-islam rally.
FollowChrist
Wed Sep 8 2010 14:08
Of course this is a christian nation.
Anonymous
Wed Sep 8 2010 14:05
"and yeah, that is an anti-islam rally when you have a dutch racist who wants to kick all the muslims out of his country as one of the main speakers."

So I guess every service Jeremiah Wright led was an anti-American rally, making Obama anti-American??

Conservative who isn't a bigot
Wed Sep 8 2010 09:13
So you think just because the 9/11 attackers were muslims that they should all be treated like they are terrorists? and yeah, that is an anti-islam rally when you have a dutch racist who wants to kick all the muslims out of his country as one of the main speakers. you don't know what you are talking about. this is a great article...I've never seen that quote by Jon Adams before, that's very interesting. kudos to the writer.
Anonymous
Wed Sep 8 2010 09:03
"This growing animosity is undoubtedly linked to the inflammatory rhetoric being spewed by right wing politicians on a daily basis."

You don't think it has anything to do with the fact that the 9/11 terrorist were Muslims? Seriously?

These events range from Pastor Terry Jones’ "Burn a Quran Day""

That even is ridiculous. Funny how that gets people more up in arms than people burning the American flag though.

"...to the anti-Islam rally at ground zero featuring former UN ambassador John Bolton and the Dutch fascist parliamentarian Geert Wilders, who advocates banning all mosques from being built and wants to stop all Muslim immigration to his country.""

It's not an anti-Islam rally, its a "don't build the mosque here, build it somewhere else" rally.

Anonymous
Wed Sep 8 2010 02:54
Couldn't agree more.

Most Popular