See Full HTML Site

Coal Bowl has to continue

By Matthew Peaslee

Published: Thursday, September 9, 2010

Updated: Thursday, September 9, 2010

For the past four years, this week has drawn the ire of many Mountaineer fans.

It's Marshall Week.

Many feel this battle for state bragging rights is a waste of time as it should be a cakewalk for the Mountaineers year-in and year-out. Although in the past, we've seen that the game could be competitive with Marshall taking leads into the locker room at halftime on two separate occasions.

Still, WVU supporters want to nix this game as soon as the contract expires in 2012.

That would be a shame.

As the only two Division I football teams in the state of West Virginia, the Thundering Herd and Mountaineers should continue to duke it out beyond the series expiration date.

The game brings the state together and allows fans from opposing sides to engage in a showdown for Mountain State pride.

Yet, still a vast majority of people look down upon this game. The Mountaineer fan website, hailwv.com, went as far as giving 10 reasons why the Friends of Coal Bowl should not be played. In a not-so creative manner, the site listed the final scores of the past nine Coal Bowl contests, all won by the Mountaineers.

For the 10th reason, the site downgraded Governor Joe Manchin, saying this game was only established so he could "win the Huntington-area vote."

This is a sports column, not a political forum, so I have no comment on that aspect. I just know I enjoy seeing these two teams play. It gives WVU a tune-up for the rest of its grueling season and allows Marshall to have the opportunity to knock off the flagship program of the state.

But we all know this state belongs to the Old Gold and Blue.

If I haven't sold you enough, I'm going to go all David Letterman and announce the top 10 reasons WVU and Marshall should play each other each year:

1. State pride. There are two teams gunning for the hearts of West Virginia football fans – let it be decided on the field.

2. It happens everywhere else. Every year Ohio State plays at least one smaller D-1A program from Ohio every year. Akron, Ohio and Miami (Ohio) have all gotten the chance to knock off the state's powerhouse in past years.

3. The ‘Coal Bowl' is a cool name. Hey, it rhymes. I like the theme and the support and attention the game brings to the backbone industry of the state.

4. Chance of an upset. I've been a lifelong Mountaineer fan and would probably cry if the Herd upset WVU.

But it could happen.

In the annual Rocky Mountain Showdown (Colorado-Colorado State), CSU pulled off the upset in 2006 and 2009. CSU is in the Mountain West, the western version of Conference USA.

5. "We are…Marshall" is a great movie. It really has made me a closet supporter of the Herd. If you've never seen it, watch it before the game tonight. WVU is presented in a great light.

6. The tragedy. To "rise from the ashes" like the Marshall program did after the plane crash in 1970 is nothing short of remarkable. Imagine having to wait a year and scrape a team together. It wouldn't be easy, and certainly wasn't.

7. Doc Holliday. The man has had Gold and Blue running through his veins since the 70s. Now as Marshall head coach, he adorned the green and white. It'll be an interesting storyline for years to come.

8. The game doesn't hurt WVU's BCS standings. Many people are calling for the series to end because the polls look down on the schedule. Believe me, if Marshall was not there another lower level team would be in.

The Alabama's and Michigan's of college football are not going to just appear in its place to beef up WVU's schedule.

9. Money. Manchin said this game "has been an economic boost to the state." If it brings in money, how can anyone argue that it's a bad thing?

10. It's a Mountaineer vs. a Buffalo. Come on, this is a classic battle of Man vs. Wild. Bear Grylls has longed for an opportunity like this.

Whether or not those 10 reasons swayed your opinion or not, just accept the fact that this game will be played for at least another two years.

If we're lucky, it will extend for more.

 

Comments

3 comments
Anonymous
Tue Sep 14 2010 09:06
Also, the capitol needs to be moved back to Wheeling and everything south of Charleston should be sold off to Kentucky or Virginia for $100.00 and a long term home and home series with WVU against either VT or Kentucky. We will waive the $100.00 if we can get the deal done this year.

LMAO!!! Love it, cheers!

WVU B.S. Econ MBA
Sun Sep 12 2010 11:06
1. Marshall wants the game so I don't.

2. Ending the series would be a kick in the teeth to Marshall.

3. Ending the series would be a kick in the teeth to the Governor.

4. Little sister's fans are even worse than ours.

5. The "Coal Bowl" is only for WVU and Va Tech

6. We shouldn't build animosity with Doc. He should be our next Head Coach.

7. Marshall is a sissy school and we shouldn't expose ourselves to even an accidental loss to sissies.

8. Marshall shouldn't be allowed to be the only sacrifical lamb getting a big paycheck to play WVU. The other members of the WVIAC should get turns. Marshall College gets a game every 15 years.

9. Fairmont State University is better and more deserving than Marshall College.

10. They got a movie, isn't that enough?

Vote Raese
Fri Sep 10 2010 08:49
1) As for State Pride, last years game in Morgantown had the lowest home attendance of any Mountaineer game the entire season. If there was so much state pride, it would have been a sellout.

2) Ohio State plays all those ohio teams IN COLUMBUS. You will never see the Buckeyes running onto the field in Akron or Toledo. If Marshall wants to come to Morgantown every year and play, sign the contract.....oh wait they already tried that once, but refused to honor the agreement after Moss and Penny were taken down in Motown.

3) A movie is no reason to force two teams to play football. East Carolina tricked us into the home and home series over that Peter Pan movie and we shouldnt fall into that trap again.

4) A tragedy is no reason to play football - Should LSU and Louisiana Tech be forced into a home and home series to commerate Katrina? The Greatest Natural Disaster in Modern United States History Bowl?

5) The Doc Holliday storyline has worn itself out. Only people in Huntington still care. If WVU wanted him as its coach, he would be in Morgantown tommorow and MU knows it. Thats why his contract has the outrageous WVU penalty clause which, by the way, has no rational relation to any damages Marshall would incur by him leaving. Penalty clauses are invalid and WVU can buy him back for chump change.

6) There is no economic boost that is any more significant than any other home game (see comment 1) . If anything, in state money is temporarily shuffled from the north to the south. WVU and Morgantown can make as much money (out of state money which is always better) against a non FBS school at home than it can when Marshall comes to town. Morgantown and Mountaineer Field can also accommodate a lot more fans that , in turn, bring in a lot more money to the state, just not to the southern part of the state.

As a Mountaineer fan, I look forward to every game except the Marshall game. It has nothing to do with the fear of losing because thats happens with every game. It has to do with all the nasty politics and whining back and forth between fans and administrations. There is no comparison to the basketball game series either because that game doesn't define a season like it can in football, nor is there anywhere near the amount of money on the line.This series needs to end so both schools can get on with their lives and weI can continue to enjoy college football.

Also, the capitol needs to be moved back to Wheeling and everything south of Charleston should be sold off to Kentucky or Virginia for $100.00 and a long term home and home series with WVU against either VT or Kentucky. We will waive the $100.00 if we can get the deal done this year.

Most Popular