Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Homeopathic meds protested during ‘mass overdose’

Published: Sunday, February 6, 2011

Updated: Sunday, February 6, 2011 23:02

Meds

Chelsi Baker/The Daily Athenaeum

The West Virginia Skeptics group take large doses of homeopathic medicines at the Blue Moose Saturday as a protest of the drugs being used to treat illnesses.

Tim Nelms said "goodbye, cruel world," just before he and other members of the West Virginia Skeptics group took an overdose of homeopathic medicine at the Blue Moose Cafe Saturday night.

The event was part of the "10:23 Campaign," a protest movement that began in England in response to outdated homeopathic medicines being covered by the national heath care system.

Twenty-three cities in 10 countries participated in simultaneous protests, according to the campaign's website.

"Our main goal is to show that there's nothing in it," Nelms said.

Members of the group took homeopathic remedies for sleep in pill and liquid form, which were 1 million times the strength of a recommended dose.

"We are doing this as a show of solidarity with our friends in England who are outraged that they have to pay for this stuff. It has no medical basis whatsoever," Nelms said.

The group filmed the protest and plans to post the video on the campaign's website.

Homeopathy, which was created in 1796 by German physician Samuel Hahnemann, is considered a pseudoscience.

Proponents of homeopathy claim that water retains "the spirt" of herbal substances. By diluting herbs in water hundreds of times, homeopaths claim to be increasing their strength.

"One of the common misconceptions with this is that homeopathy and herbal medicine are the same," said

Gerold Turner, member of the group.

Medically, there is no benefit to using homeopathic remedies, and there is no risk involved with taking mass doses.

Turner said the main goal of group is to examine paranormal and supernatural claims with scientific reason.

"We have a book club, a religion of the month club, discussion groups, you name it," said Butch Campione, group member. "We're just trying to promote scientific thought."

The group is affiliated with the Morgantown Coalition of Reason, which seeks to

promote logic over superstition.

It has recently begun to focus on charitable work around the city such as volunteering at the Ronald McDonald House and the Bartlett House. It also helped to clean trash along the Rail Trail.

"We do a lot more than just pray for people, I can tell you that," Campione said.

To learn more about the 10:23 Campaign and its mission, visit www.1023.org.uk.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

9 comments

Anonymous
Wed Feb 23 2011 10:32
The last comment in this article by Miss Campione sums up their agenda, pot shots at all religions that practice prayer or believe differently of them. If you claim to do so much good around your community shunning or making fun of a large portion of it's population is hardly productive. Furthermore, it discredits anything "positive" listed before that last statement. The church that I attended while in Morgantown was active in the farmers market, Ronald McDonald House, Friends of Cheat, local food drives, clean up the night projects, counseling (both religious and secular forms) art and environmental awareness and many more "I can tell you that".........oh and as you so eloquently put it praying for people. We also accepted you regardless of whether you believe in the big bang, evolution, worshiped the Flying Spaghetti Monster or prayed to Jesus Christ, Buddha, Mohammad...what have you. Your posturing is arrogant and lends your position no credit. I have friends who are Atheists and enjoy many running dialogues on various forms of discussion including the most evident topic. I don't thump a bible and they don't make fun of my prayer, we're simply two sides of a fence that get along together. If you want people to listen to your cause/ideals/practices etc. you need to gain there ears and you've failed here horribly by showing a lack of maturity/empathy flaunted in your own words. By no means am I bashing you, only suggesting that community outreach and actions are completely without merit if you continue to deepen a rift between your group and the other that you choose to make fun of..........and also outnumbers you. With that said, you and your friends are always welcome at my dinner table regardless of belief and we don't have to pray before we eat.
Gerald
Fri Feb 11 2011 17:38
You are right, you apparently don't live in reality. Nowhere did I say I wanted these products to be outlawed, just that consumers should have the proper information about them to make an informed decision. If wanting people to know the truth makes me a bully, so be it.
Mike
Thu Feb 10 2011 15:59
And whose "in reality" are you referring to? Not mine, or millions of other people, who see homeopathy as a valid option for health issues. You are not a skeptic, but a bully; who wants to "legislate" or "dictate" what the rest of us can or cannot do in regards to our health. But you're a bit late... The AMA, from as early as 1910, has been trying to outlaw homeopathy, and any other disciplines, that could potentially cut into their profits.
Gerald
Thu Feb 10 2011 11:23
I don't care if people use them or not, but they should have the information to make an informed decision. These products are marketed at being effective at combating illness, when in reality they are nothing more than sugar pills.
Anonymous
Wed Feb 9 2011 20:45
If it can't hurt, why do you care if others choose to use homeopathic remedies? Wouldn't you agree that individuals should have the right to choose what type of medical treatments they receive, whether they be allopathic, homeopathic, herbal or otherwise? Surely, in this day and age, our insurance companies should not be dictating our health care choices, but they do.
Gerald
Wed Feb 9 2011 18:11
We can measure the results of homeopathy with the tools we currently possess, and the results show that homeopathy doesn't work.
Anonymous
Wed Feb 9 2011 12:28
Right Gerald. If we cannot measure something with the tools we currently possess, then it doesn't exist. Great logic; last used to prove the earth is flat.
If you don't understand, or care to research the issue; then leave it alone.

Mike

Gerald
Wed Feb 9 2011 12:10
Of course homeopathy has no list of side effects, since there are no active ingredients. It's just water or sugar pills.
Mike Kimble
Wed Feb 9 2011 10:27
What a bunch of idiots. It figures a "doctor" is the main spokesperson. Why not take an overdose, or even a standard dose, of conventional drugs and see what happens?
At least with remedies, there are not the list of side effects that takes two pages to list in print ads. I guess those two pages of side effects/ ailments that result in taking prescription meds somehow prove they are better??
Maybe this group could take some pins and needles to themselves and "dis-prove" acupuncture next.




log out