Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Judicial board orders re-election

Details to be determined by Office of Student Affairs

Published: Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Updated: Wednesday, April 13, 2011 01:04

SGA

Brooke Cassidy/The Daily Athenaeum

Members of the SGA’s Judicial Board discuss violations that occurred during the campaigning period of the Student Government elections Tuesday night at the College of Law.

Members of the Judicial Board ordered a revote of the Student Government Association elections at West Virginia University Tuesday night due to multiple allegations of tampering with votes.

During a Judicial Board hearing to address campaign violations, an issue was raised that multiple candidates from both the Pirate and Fusion parties were responsible for voter fraud. James Bailey, Judicial Board chair, said because there was a lack of evidence to single out any particular person, a revote would be best.

"We felt there was an abundance of evidence on both sides of mass voter fraud. For that reason, we have decided not to certify this election and to order a revote," he said.

Bailey said the details of the revote will be determined by the Office of Student Affairs as "soon as possible." The Judicial Board will issue a statement today explaining the logic behind its decision and offer advice for Student Affairs to consider when determining the details of the revote, he said.

Monday, the leaders from both parties endorsed a revote because they did not want the matter to be determined in court, which could affect the image of SGA. They agreed a revote would be best for the students.

Jonathan Storage, member of the Judicial Board, read from a statement following the decision, reminding candidates of Article 6 of the SGA Elections Code dealing with fair campaign practices.

"We wish that you would go foreword with this (Article 6) in mind with the upcoming revote, because the certification will come before this board again and we will address any further issues of campaign violations," Storage said.

Board members also issued decisions on outcomes of campaign violations presented during Tuesday's meeting.

SGA Vice President Ron Cheng and SGA Executive Jamie Chapman were accused by Gov. Josh Snyder of using computers in the College of Law to access the Votenet system and falsify students' votes. The Board decided to dismiss the charge due to lack of evidence.

"I'm happy," Cheng said. "My name is cleared now, they have been after me for a while, and it's good that in the end, I'm okay."

Pirate Party candidates Alyssa Mariano and Bryanna DeFazio were levied $30 fines for illegal campaign practices outside of the Towers residence halls. According to the violation, both candidates asked students for their 700 numbers to vote for them.

Courtney Bertol, also a candidate with the Pirate Party, received a $10 fine for illegally placing a campaign poster inside of a classroom.

Violations against Pirate Party members Philip Berry, Alex Folio, Joe Harmon, Maranio and Collins Youngblood were also dismissed.

Fines from election violations are billed to the candidates' student accounts and are payable online. If a candidate fails to pay their fine, they will receive a hold on their account and will be unable to register for classes or graduate.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

14 comments

Anonymous
Wed Apr 13 2011 21:54
I'm pleased to see that others are frustrated with the Judicial Board's decision to dismiss the charges. Where is the accountability for wrongdoing? SGA is meant to be a representation of the student body, and I am absolutely ashamed that these unethical, righteous, irreverent people are who is responsible for representing me as a student at WVU. I was a staunch supporter of the Fusion Party because I believed they were sincere in their message of competence, transparency, and good faith. I choose not to vote in the re-election and I think all who share my frustration should refrain from voting also as a show of solidarity. Take a stand.
Anonymous
Wed Apr 13 2011 20:13
Both parties cheated plain and simple. I had pirates offer to buy my dinner and knock on my apartment door and invite themselves into my apartment. They even walked into my room and grabbed my laptop for me to vote. Not cool. I thought they were going to rob me. Ron Cheng is nuts too but that doesn't mean that he doesnt have the right to support one party or another. A revote is dumb. I know all these people and they all worked hard. Both sides cheat. It happens. Get over it.
Anonymous
Wed Apr 13 2011 20:04
Mcculloch/Casto 2010 revote
Anonymous
Wed Apr 13 2011 18:04
Going on University Programs and stealing 700 numbers is illegal. It's called Identity Theft. Check out the DA tomorrow ;)
Inquiring Mind
Wed Apr 13 2011 13:25
Dear Anonymous posting on Wed Apr 13 2011 at 09:36:

Exactly what Federal Laws did Mr. Cheng violate? Why do you think petty Student Body Elections would end up in a "real" court?

The only applicable Federal Laws to the SGA election would be regarding unauthorized access (hacking) of a computer system. Giving someone your username and password, then they log in using your information is only unethical - NOT illegal.

Thanks,
Inquiring Mind

Anonymous
Wed Apr 13 2011 12:05
You people and your comically exaggerated hatred of Ron Cheng. If you're here simply as Josh Snyder's lackeys, then you're brainless. If you're here to kiss Snyder's ring, then you're the lowest of the low, eagerly lapping up the corrupt character assassination he's known for.

His "complaint" against Cheng was a laughable farce, based on his personal testimony of a series of rambling, unconnected events, culminating in the damning evidence that Jamie Chapman's engine was COLD. Snyder is a disingenuous man without the good sense to even gather another witness to lie for him.

And as for the Fusion party's cheating. If you went to the meeting last night, you'd know that the ONLY complaint against anyone affiliated with the Fusion party was Snyder's aforementioned cavalcade of incompetence. Meanwhile, Pirate Party candidates Alyssa Mariano, Bryana DeFazio, Philip Berry, Colins Youngblood and Alex Folio were caught ON VIDEO breaking elections code.

But what of the valiant leaders of the Pirate Party? What did they have to say when these complains were made known? Nothing. Of course, that may be due to the fact that Brummage and Harmon were also caught on video campaigning within 30 feet of Clark Hall (a violation of Elections Code) and then voting for people on their phones (a HUGE violation of Elections Code).

If the Fusion Party leadership was not so bound and determined to throw its governors under the bus and call redo, there might be actual consequences for these brazen rules violations. As it is, both parties' leadership are ready to whitewash the whole incident and just say, "Eh, what can ya do?"

There's actually a lot you can do. That's why we have a Judicial Board to hear complaints and act on them. But I guess that would require its members to do something other than equivocate and wring their hands. The real irony of the situation: it has shown us just how low everyone in this equation is willing to go to appear so righteous.

Anonymous
Wed Apr 13 2011 09:40
There is a difference between helping people vote with their consent and voting for people without their knowledge. One apparently gets you a $30 fine for illegal campaign practices and the other one gets you thrown in jail!
Anonymous
Wed Apr 13 2011 09:36
"I'm happy," Cheng said. "My name is cleared now, they have been after me for a while, and it's good that in the end, I'm okay."

HAHAHAHAHA something tells me this is far from over. You can not break federal laws and then think you are going to walk away clean, worse yet brag about it prematurely in the newspaper. Ron Cheng, you alone are responsible for tainting three SGA elections. We can not trust that there has been one honest SGA election since you got involved. You are a disgrace to the student body and to anyone that invested their time over the years to getting involved with SGA to actually help students. I hope that this comes out in court so that you can be expelled or go to jail. As a student and former SGA member you make me sick!

Anonymous
Wed Apr 13 2011 09:33
The FUSION Ticket did 3 great things.

1. Cheat

2. Complain about everything the Pirate Party did. That's all they did. The Pirate Party were more chill about the election and only threatened complaints

3. Cheat again

Anonymous
Wed Apr 13 2011 08:50
I went to the Judicial Board meeting last night, and contrary to what the article says, every single complaint except one was directed toward Pirate Party candidates. Furthermore, the complaint against the Fusion Party was against two people helping the campaign, not any actual candidates of the party. I am disappointed with the misleading wording at the beginning of the article. They even say towards the end that three Pirate Party Governor candidates were found guilty and several others dismissed. No Fusion Party members were mentioned, because no complaints were filed against them and heard.
Anonymous
Wed Apr 13 2011 06:57
Poor Cheng, it is sad that he thinks "in the end" he is ok. In the end, he will pay for his lies and actions. Sounds like this matter needs to go to court if the Judicial board is not capable of doing what is right and fair.
Anonymous
Wed Apr 13 2011 02:23
Oh god not again, I really don't want to see that nasty ugly red head talking to me for 4 hours at the Lair
Anonymous
Wed Apr 13 2011 02:22
Who did the investigating...the cops from superbad?
Anonymous
Wed Apr 13 2011 02:04
What a joke. I bet even less students vote this time around!






log out