College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

Editorial: Study highlights need for texting ban

Published: Tuesday, November 17, 2009

Updated: Tuesday, November 17, 2009

The need for a nationwide ban on texting while driving has been reinforced by new evidence showing and increased number of drivers are taking part in this practice.

The Pew Internet & American Life Project recently conducted a survey this past summer of 800 teens in four U.S. cities.

The study found 26 percent of all teenagers 16 to 17 years old have texted while driving, with approximately half having been in a car of someone who was driving and texting.

According to The Washington Post, teenagers told Pew researchers their reasons for texting while behind the wheel: getting directions, finding friends and flirting.

"Many teens understand the risks of texting behind the wheel," Amanda Lenhart, co-author of the report, told the Post. "But the desire to stay connected is so strong for teens and their parents that safety sometimes takes a backseat to staying in touch with friends and family."

The report also states teens had attempted to restrict their texting to just stopped moments at red lights.

Such a large amount of teenagers is cause for concern. Remember, these are young, new drivers without much experience.

It is disconcerting to see that so many drivers freely engage in a practice that distracts their full attention from the road.

In the age of the cell phone, however, it is to be expected. But that doesn’t mean it should be tolerated.

For this reason, we need a national banning on cell phones and texting while driving – because texting alone isn’t the only cause for concern.

According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 81 percent of U.S. residents admit to using their phones while driving.

To illustrate the growing cause for concern, take a quick look outside. A simple glance at the road when walking can show how many drivers have their heads down with one hand on the wheel while furiously texting.

Count how many people have their cell phones pressed to their ear as they attempt to navigate their cars through busy, narrow Morgantown streets.

The study found drivers knew about the dangers of texting while driving and engaging in practices distracting their focus from the road.

Yet they continue.

As cell phones become more and more complex, we need new laws ensuring the safety of everyone on the road.

While we recognize the uphill battle to prevent drivers from texting, we see benefits from outlawing the practice.

Cell phones do have their use when driving – like calling emergency crews for a wreck, staying in communication with families for emergencies or even finding directions.

But those purposes shouldn’t come at the potential cost of the safety on our roadways.
 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

11 comments

Dave
Thu Nov 19 2009 20:26
db- you are right. Its not unenforceable laws thats going to save lives- its people actually using their own common sense and not doing those things.
db
Thu Nov 19 2009 18:24
People are idiots, hands down. They think nothing bad will ever happen to them or anyone they care about. What will it take for them to learn not to text/eat/drink/whatever and drive? Everyone needs to wise up and realize that they are not the only ones on the road before they get hurt themselves or an innocent victim..
eightwednesday
Thu Nov 19 2009 12:09
As someone working for an agency working on this, it's basically unenforceable. Right now the bulk of the research is going toward how to enforce this as well as how we can curtail texting while driving while still making phones usable in the event of an emergency or usable for passengers (some have suggested that cars interfere with cell phones or if a cell provider sees a phone moving from tower to tower at a certain speed--both of which have flaws for passengers and emergency calls).

I wish stricter laws were the answer. I do. But a police officer can't see through the door of your car to see you holding the phone below the wheel and you could be looking down for a number of reasons. Stricter laws don't give cops x-ray vision, sorry to say.

Besides, states can outlaw texting while driving all they want, but there are so many other distractions out there that taking one out of the game isn't going to change that much... we still have digital billboards, navigation systems, complex radios and audio devices, and so forth.

Dave
Thu Nov 19 2009 12:01
"Sounds like a two-part freedom infringement to me, banning the cell and then the police forcing access to it. "

Thats what concerns me. The enforcement of it is going to be arbitrary, and the only way to prove your innocence is to let the police/government go through your phone or even seize your phone as evidence- that is one possible way of enforcement, and that isn't acceptable.

"It's just as easily enforced as a seatbelt law"

Which isn't really enforced that much. There is a not insignificant amount of people that do not wear their seat belt and never get pulled over, and even if they did they wouldn't start wearing their seatbelts.

Ryan Post
Thu Nov 19 2009 10:27
It's just as easily enforced as a seatbelt law. If you think you can't tell when someone is texting, you're ignorant.

I got hit on University while on my motorcycle waiting at the light at Stewart St by a guy texting who just left off his brake. So even when stopped, it's still a hazard!

Erin
Wed Nov 18 2009 23:54
The only way you could know if the driver was texting would be if the police officer had probable cause in order to demand access to the phone, but probable cause is subjective. Basically, he'd could say he saw you texting, true ot not, and you'd have to turn over your phone. Sounds like a two-part freedom infringement to me, banning the cell and then the police forcing access to it.
Dave
Wed Nov 18 2009 18:17
I just don't see how this is going to be effectively enforced. You see someone looking down in the car, they could be messing with the stereo, reading the newspaper, eating, etc... (none of those are illegal to my knowledge), so you do you know FOR SURE that they're texting? I just think its rather unenforceable. You can put the law on the books but I just don't see it having any effect. The biggest culprit of texting while driving is young people, and most young people drink before they are 21 despite that being illegal. They'll go ahead and break that law too. The real solution is for an increased use of speech-to-text and text-to-speech technology on mobile phones.
db
Wed Nov 18 2009 17:24
Just like the article says: "To illustrate the growing cause for concern, take a quick look outside. A simple glance at the road when walking can show how many drivers have their heads down with one hand on the wheel while furiously texting."

I used to work in Fairmont right off of the interstate and when I went outside I had a clear view of drivers, 6 out of every 10 had their heads down texting, so it's not hard to see.

And answer this for me, why wouldnt you want a law like this? Is it really worth losing your life or someone else's because you just couldn't wait to read or reply to a text message? Also, it's hardly ever the texting driving who gets injured, it's an innocent person that had 2 hands on the wheel and was paying attention. It's really bad that people can't leave their phones alone when they're driving.

Dave
Wed Nov 18 2009 16:13
How, exactly, are the police going to prove someone is texting while driving? Its going to be pretty difficult to see for sure from outside the vehicle. Are they going to be allowed to demand access to your phone to check your sent messages?
db
Wed Nov 18 2009 14:52
There are ways to enforce this, the laws just need to be stricter. If you are caught texting while driving and it 's your first offense, your license should be suspended and you should have to pay a fine of no less than $500. Second time, 60 day suspension and $1000 fine and so on. It's ridiculous that these laws aren't stricter and it's a shame people don't use common sense when driving, there are lives on the line and no one cares.
frank
Wed Nov 18 2009 10:52
No way to enforce this. Waste of time.






log out