College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

Excessive bank fees continue to burden college students

By Denita Jones

|

Published: Monday, November 2, 2009

Updated: Monday, November 2, 2009

ATM

A student withdraws cash from the PNC Bank ATM outside the Mountainlair Monday. A New Jersey man has filed suit against PNC alleging the bank manipulates the order in which it subtracts debit charges from customers’ accounts in order to maximize overdraft fees.

 

 

As college students, handling money seems to be a hard lesson to learn.

A lesson which, unfortunately, many of us learn through experience.

One thing I’ve learned is that banks can sometimes get you into trouble before you’re even aware of it – then you’re stuck trying to figure out what to do with those red numbers staring you in the face.

For many national banks, fees have become a major source of revenue.

And those banks have plenty of fees to utilize. ATM fees, minimum balance fees, "per use" fees (such as a charge each time you opt to use your card as debit rather than credit) and monthly service charges are just a few ways your bank can stick it to you.

Overdraft fees are my worst enemy.

The bad news is the fees aren’t getting any better, as bank fees reached a new record high this year.

According to Bankrate’s 2009 checking survey, nonsufficient funds fees (NSF) or bounced check fees rose 2.1 percent. This brought the average overdraft fee from $28.95 to a new high of $29.58 per fee.

This isn’t anything new.

Banks have continued to raise their fees every year. In 1998, the average overdraft fee was about $21.57.

While some banks have competitively lowered their fees, they are still outnumbered 8-to-1 to those banks who have decided to raise their fees.

I get so infuriated when I do the math. (This rarely happens, I’m a writer – I don’t do math.)

It seems ridiculous that banks can charge almost $30 for $5 overdraft.

It’s unfair banks raise their fees over two percent, yet money market accounts, on average, pay only 0.32 percent.

This leaves the consumer waiting about five years to yield an average of 2.19 percent on MMA.

Some banks are even instituting a tiered system, charging even more for the second through the fifth overdraft during a given 12 month period that you overdraw from your account.

Of the banks surveyed by Bankrate, 17 percent have a tier that averages $36.19 after you bounce your fifth check.

I understand that chronic mistakes should be addressed, but charging more than $36 seems a bit steep to me.

It doesn’t end with the overdraft fee – some banks even charge a fee for every day that the overdraft goes unpaid.

And after two to four weeks, your account can be closed.

Banks just get dirtier and dirtier by means of handling our accounts. I imagine that in the contract you signed to open an account, they failed to mention how they apply charges in a single day.

With multiple debit transactions on the same day, the bank applies the charges by amount (from largest to smallest) and not by the order in which you swiped your card.

This is troubling because the account may have bounced after the largest debit was applied. Each transaction after gets a nice little fee tacked on to it.

Something to look forward to: there is current legislation concerning bank fees.

A congressional bill (H.R. 1456) was introduced in March that would amend the Truth in Lending Act to address overdraft protection programs and services.

According to Bankrate, this has caused some of the top national banks, such as Bank of America, Chase and Wells Fargo, to change some of their policies concerning overdrafts.

Let’s hope this becomes a trend – or it looks like I’ll be investing in a piggy bank after college.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

7 comments

Your average Joe
Fri Nov 27 2009 14:06
I think the only way to stop these EXCESSIVE fees SCAMS is for people to STOP dealing with National banks and go do business with state run banks because this way your STATE regulates them and they DO NOT get away with even half of the stuff these national banks do.

Oh and if you are waiting for congress to pass a bill to stop the national banks from their DELIBERATE THEFTS, do NOT hold your breath because they get PAID BIG MONEY by the bank lobbyists to allow them to RAPE, PILLAGE and PLUNDER their customers.

CathAnn
Thu Nov 19 2009 13:10
D....I do agree with all you said, but you need to bear in mind that there are some very responsible people out there who make a mistake every now and again. My situation occurred at the loss of my job and the stress I was under caused me to make a very costly error while using my debit card. I simply forgot about my monthly car payment that comes out the same day each month. My bank took that car payment first and then took 8 other debit card transactions causing me to go into the red in a bad way. I'm fully aware of MY responsibility in what happened, but my bank did nothing........other than accept transactions when I was IN THE RED. I feel that when an item posts and draws you negative the bank should not allow that card usage until the account is back in good standing with the bank. I was charged 9 fees of $38.00 each. My bank refuned me 2 of those, making my fees $266.00. It is about personal responsibility, but stressors and major life changes played a huge part in my debacle. I would hope, D, that you never make a mistake with your checkbook.
Bank of America Rep.
Wed Nov 4 2009 07:43
Most banks will also post the largest amount debited from you account first and the lesser amount last. This in turn will overdraw your account in a much greater way and have a much greater chance to overdraw it more times resulting it more fees. Also, by federal law, banks can only place an amount on hold from your account for a 24 hour period and must then return that amount to your account. So if using a visa check card as a credit card purchase, make sure what ever your buying post to your account within 24 hours or that money will be made available for your to use again on other purchase just like you never spent it.
Teletech employees have been working for BoA for quite a while. I am sure quite a few of them can tell you some great stories and loop holes about how the banks change fees to the unaware.
A student and frustrated bank customer
Tue Nov 3 2009 16:30
The rising overdraft fees really upset me--at my bank ALL overdraft fees are 37.50 regardless of transaction amount.
While I have to agree that physically documenting and keeping track of personal finances is vital to avoiding overdrafts, online banking is NOT helpful, at least with the bank I use. I tried to keep track of the transactions myself but was confused when trying to balance my checkbook with the online system. I then foolishly attempted to rely only on the online transaction list and got into a whole heap of trouble because transactions do not post in order and often do not show up right away. Not to mention any transactions from 2:00pm Friday til 11:59pm on Monday don't post until Tuesday. There are many complicated loops in what would normally appear to be a simple system. A bank manager attempted to explain the policy to me but some of it was difficult to understand. We aren't all bankers; how are we expected to compare banks for better service and rates when many banks have different systems and policies?
So the obvious and only solid solution to avoiding overdrafts is to keep track of and document every expense--a bit difficult but possible--when you are motivated by exorbitant fees.
Morgantown Bank Employee
Tue Nov 3 2009 08:56
I would suggest either downloading (Mint.com), or purchasing a personal financing software (Quicken 2008) at Best Buy, Walmart or any computer/electronics department. It is a great tool for seeing where you currently stand, where you are headed (Cash Inflow) and more importantly where you've been (Historical Expenses) financially. This software truly disciplines you in to controling your spending. I currently use Quicken 2008 and it's the best computer software investment I've ever made.

Don't want to do this?? Then open an E*Trade checking account - They reimburse you ALL ATM fees. Best checking account I've ever had.

Faculty - Wvu.
Tue Nov 3 2009 08:26
It really is a nice thought to be proactive with your personal finances, but when the University makes a deal with an out of state bank that a majority of students, faculty and staff do not use, this equals a fee every time someone decides to take out a few dollars. I'm sure we all loved reading vague promotions from the University about how PNC bank will serve the WVU community when it all really boils down to money given to someone.
D
Tue Nov 3 2009 08:01
Bank fees are pretty outrageous, but a simple solution is to be proactive with your personal finances. Read up on what fees your bank charges, and most importantly, keep track of your spending! With online access to your bank account and the plethora of software available to help you keep track of your checkbook, there's really no excuse for overdrawing your account anymore- you just need to be diligent in keeping track of where your money is going! Personal responsibility- if you don't overdraft, it doesn't matter what the bank fee for it is.






log out