Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Massey Energy Co. has a history of disregarding safety

Published: Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Updated: Wednesday, April 7, 2010 23:04

Mine

A large drill and fan work above Massey Energy’s Upper Big Branch Coal Mine, Wednesday.

The eyes of the nation are upon West Virginia at this moment – glaring at us, disapprovingly, distrustfully, as usual – as the most serious American mining disaster in 26 years took place Monday in the backyard of our capital city.

At least 25 miners are dead, more are injured, and of course, the governor was on vacation.

How perfect.

I am not comfortable with the idea of using the unnecessary, avoidable deaths of so many innocent people to make a political point, so I won't do it. This is in a realm somewhere far, far distant from partisan politics.

The vacationing Friend-of-Coal governor is a moderate Democrat, the post-modern coal baron CEO of the corporation that owns the exploded mine a staunch, unapologetic conservative Republican.

I am interested neither in their party registration nor in anyone else's right now. I'm interested in serious, brutal honesty, and here it is:

The Upper Big Creek mine, owned by Richmond, Va.-based Massey Energy, incurred an astonishing 1,342 safety citations in the past five years, worth $1.89 million in fines. It received 50 violations in the last month alone, including 12 serious violations for failure to properly vent explosive methane gas.

Three workers died at Upper Big Creek in various other incidents between 1998 and Monday's explosion.

As Kevin Stricklin, coal administrator for the federal Mine Safety & Health Administration said, "The operator (Massey) "was aware of some of these conditions."

In January 2006, two miners died in a fire at the Aracoma mine in Logan County, W. Va., a mine operated by a Massey subsidiary.

The company racked up $1.5 million in federal fines for that incident, at the time the largest fine ever levied by MSHA. (That number is likely to be exceeded by a factor of several once the fine for the Upper Big Branch incident is tallied.)

For good measure, the subsidiary pled guilty to 10 criminal charges in connection with the Aracoma mine disaster in 2006.

Not that Massey only racks up records for putting miners at risk – the company doesn't much care about the rest of us either. In 2008, Massey was hit with the largest penalty ever issued by the Environmental Protection Agency for its stream-dumping practices. The company ultimately agreed to pay the government more than $30 million.

No problem for Massey. The multi-state conglomerate reported net profits of over $100 million in 2009.

Don Blankenship, the aforementioned CEO, paid for the successful 2004 campaign of state Supreme Court Justice Brent Benjamin, who then promptly cast the deciding vote in Massey's favor in a standing civil action involving a competing mine operation.

This fight went all the way to U.S. Supreme Court, with the justices issuing a decision forcing Benjamin to recuse himself from a re-hearing of the case.

Massey has further managed to remove the United Mine Workers of America from every single one of its mining operations, both underground and surface, although a lone processing plant remains a union shop.

Massey has lost at least two civil suits brought by the UMWA in attempts to force the company to hire union miners. The company has chosen to pay heavy penalties rather than allow any of its mines to unionize.

Meanwhile, Blankenship argued this week his operation has an above-average safety record. That's interesting: A 2008 study found that Massey had racked up more safety violations than every other West Virginia mining corporation combined.

Well played, gentlemen. You've assembled some of the most unsafe working conditions in all of American mining and thoroughly broken the union that has for a century successfully fought for dramatic improvements in worker safety.

Along the way, you've paid record fines, built a massive slurry impoundment above an elementary school, and even managed to buy a judge.

I hope it's worth the blood on your hands.

West Virginia Rep. Nick Rahal, chairman of the House Committee on National Resources, said: "I want to know why this tragedy happened. We will seek answers about the cause of this disaster."

If the congressman is serious, I suggest he begin his quest at Massey headquarters in Richmond.
 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

12 comments

Anonymous
Mon Apr 19 2010 12:42
Massey is an atrocious excuse for a coal company. If the company would have spent $12 to fix a light on a transport van, my father would still be alive today. Granted mining is a dangerous job, all miners know this, but the mine companies have obligations to ensure the mines are as safe as possible. It is sad to see how much greed will overtake common sense and adherance to safety laws. I hope Massey gets sued for everything they own.
edog355
Mon Apr 12 2010 10:53
"I hate don blankenship as much as the next person---but let's do some fact-checking. He doesn't own the Mine- He is the CEO of Massey, which owns the mine. Who owns Massey? stakeholders. " Are you implying that "stakeholders" are responsible because they own a share of stock? That's ridiculous. Stockholders don't make the everyday decisions - the corporate board does. That is where you have to take your criminal complaints. If the legal protections around corporate boards were removed, you would see some serious actions taken to protect workers in the mine. If nobody is ever held accountable, then the same problems will continue - or get worse.
Anonymous
Sat Apr 10 2010 18:03
Safety is a matter of educated crews working together to make a safe worksite. Regluations wirtten by lawyers will not make the mines safe. An unsafe mine is a business liability and anyone who thinks otherwise should be fired. Before the mine is reopened everone should be trained to observe for any possible problem. Management must stand up for anyone that points out a possible problem and accept that fixing the problem may lower productivity for a short time but it is the only way to run a mine.
R. Moffett, Richmond, VA
Fri Apr 9 2010 09:22
I'm a life-long Virginian and the proud parent of a WVU graduate. In my opinion, Massey Energy, headquartered in Virginia has willfully disregarded safety knowing that, because of the severe lack of alternative employment, WV miners will be effectively forced to continue to work in unsafe conditions in order to sustain their families. In my opinion, Massey Energy, corporately, and it's executives and directors, personally, should be subject to the most severe financial and criminal penalties provided in law. The time is long past due when mine owners must be held fully accountable for their actions, which in my opinion in this case, represent corporate murder of innocent employees. The fine people of West Virginia deserve much better than the shameful treatment they receive at the hands of greedy and callous
Anonymous
Thu Apr 8 2010 16:16
Coal kills.

They ignore safety violations and murder workers. The ones that get out have black lung. Coal slurry then runs into our water supply and kills all the residents. Dirty coal fills the air and destroys our lungs.

The only reason they take these jobs is because there are no others and there are no others because we rely on these jobs.

End coal use forever.

Anonymous
Thu Apr 8 2010 15:55
Unions exist to protect the worker from gross oversights and abuses by the special powers that employers are granted. We do not live in a society where are true employer-employee legal contract exists anymore, and this is why unions are incredibly important.
Anonymous
Thu Apr 8 2010 15:09
unions would have allowed the miners to refuse to work in such conditions. They already hire workers that are union to repair the mine, when they decide to repair it. Don Blankenship is slime.
Anonymous
Thu Apr 8 2010 13:30
As if a lack of unions is the reason for the disaster...Unions get in the way and hurt the workers in the longrun. Massey shouldn't HAVE to hire union workers.
Anonymous
Thu Apr 8 2010 12:56
mining is a dangerous job, miners enter those mines knowing this. If they don't want a dangerous job, go work at walmart.
Anonymous
Thu Apr 8 2010 11:08
The article does not refer to Don Blankenship as the owner, it states that he is the CEO of the corporation which owns the mine. It is a very well written article which makes excellent points. Greed will always come before human life.
Anonymous
Thu Apr 8 2010 09:49
Shareholders**
Anonymous
Thu Apr 8 2010 09:47
I hate don blankenship as much as the next person---but let's do some fact-checking. He doesn't own the Mine- He is the CEO of Massey, which owns the mine. Who owns Massey? stakeholders.






log out