College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

With disaster relief, maybe the first call shouldn’t go to US

Published: Thursday, January 21, 2010

Updated: Thursday, January 21, 2010

As you read this, the multitude of Haitians desperately seeking help wait.

After their capital city was ravaged by a 7.0 magnitude earthquake last week, the population, most of whom were previously living in poverty, are currently forced to rely on international aid.

The world has responded. But we must ask ourselves, what is our country doing to help? At this point, the only successful route to supply the country with much needed food and medical supplies is by air.

Reports are abound of roads blocked with debris and the port’s main pier splintered beneath the waves, leaving the inadequate airport to sustain all incoming supplies.

This creates an incredible obstacle for the many countries and aid programs that have heard the cries for help and are responding quickly with planes full of supplies.

Our government’s first response, however, should have been of a different magnitude.

Much of the problems arose when the Haitian government released control of its airspace to the United States.

The reports indicate the stunned Haitian government signed a memorandum of understanding, relinquishing control of the airport, with its single working runway, to the United States.

This seems to be our government’s response to most crises. The New York Times reported aid officials were accusing the U.S. of solely concerning itself with stationing troops and lifting American citizens out of Haiti.

Jarry Emmanuel, air logistics officer for the World Food Program, told The New York Times the Haitian airport is currently managing 200 flights in and out, most being for our military.

Since this accusation, the U.S. has managed to free up more airspace, but the damage has been done.

Our top priority seems to be obtaining and sustaining control of a country whose government is weakened by a natural disaster.

Why was it our government’s first priority to make sure troops were stationed rather than to ensure medical supplies, fresh water and food is delivered to those in desperately need?

Planes carrying these supplies were diverted elsewhere due to our nation’s concern with controlling the situation, ultimately causing as much as a 24-hour delay in shipment of supplies.

The Guardian reported that a Medecins Sans Frontieres (also known as Doctors without Borders) cargo plane, carrying an inflatable surgical hospital, was denied landing and rerouted to Samana, in the Dominican Republic.

I can’t imagine the reasoning to deny a cargo plane transporting supplies to accommodate 100 sick patients, provide sterile medical equipment and an environment to conduct surgery just for the U.S. to secure military positions.

Haiti needs all the help it can get.

However, we should probably ask ourselves why our nation’s disaster relief plans are so askew.

When Hurricane Katrina destroyed New Orleans, we weren’t too proud of the way our response plans were implemented then, either.

Perhaps we should reevaluate our planning skills and figure out why things keep going wrong when we need precise, sufficient decisions that are executed without flaw.
 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

4 comments

WVU Mom
Fri Jan 29 2010 13:22
I agree with Dave, John, and the Sgt. This article is totally inaccurate and unfair. This information is completely unfounded. You should post a retraction.
Sgt. Barker, US Army, Military Police Corps
Sat Jan 23 2010 09:46
I am appalled at the lack of research you have done for this article! A quick glance at any news outlet (except the DA) will inform you that the U.S. Navy has sent a 250 bed hospital ship, the USS Comfort, along with 550 medical staff. On top of that, the 82nd airborne division sent 1500 troops to distibute 153,000 Meals ready to eat (MREs) as well as engineers to rebuild basic utilities, hospitals, shelters and roads. the Army Medical corps has sent 300 medical staff and surgeons.
You obviously have no idea what the US military does. The military is always the first to respond to any disaster worldwide because they have the resources ready, always. There is no other organization in the world that carries out more humanitarian aid than they do. Now, stop watching movies for your knowledge of the military and do some real research or stop trying to be a journalist. There are enough people who have no clue, spreading disinformation about us, we don't need anymore.
John in Charleston
Fri Jan 22 2010 20:14
Ditto, Dave's comments. The Haitian police are shooting looters. Regrettable, but not subject to second guessing. Without a military and police presence, aid workers would have to leave. Denita Jones can be forgiven for not having any life experience to draw upon, but now, get a clue and do the right thing by journalism standards and re-write the story!
Dave
Fri Jan 22 2010 11:16
Wow, are you serious? Can you imagine what would have happened if the US had NOTbeen the first one there? Who was going to run the airport? The Haitian government? It was in shambles. The UN? They weren't there and they aren't effective at doing much of anything. Did you even consider that, without a little bit of security, people would have made a run on the airport, street gangs would have stolen much of the supplies, aid workers and Haitians would have been killed, and there would have been an even greater delay in getting aid to Haiti? This is an incredibly short-sighted article. Thank God for the American military- they are doing one heck of a job there. It's an enormous task to coordinate getting food and medical supplies for 2 million people into a small country with no infrastructure and one working runway. Who do you think could have done a better job? The UN? The French? Who? Imagine what would have happened if we had not went in right away. Many, many, many more people would have perished. And what country has stepped up with pledges of more aid than us??? NONE! It is absolutely unbelievable that you are going to sit in your office and write something like this in light of all we are doing Haiti.

Yet another completely ridiculous editorial article written by the DA staff.







log out