Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

WVU campus crime on rise?

Students should be responsible, independent and proactive

Published: Monday, November 16, 2009

Updated: Monday, November 16, 2009 23:11

When choosing a college, many incoming freshmen don't consider a low campus crime rate a priority.

However, with the recent spike of crime on the campus of West Virginia University, it makes one wonder if it will affect how potential students will view our college.

The University Police Department takes pride in sustaining one of the lowest campus crime rates.

In the face of this surge in crime, I hold onto that fact in hopes that these past few months will just been seen as a coincidence.

After the shootings at Virginia Tech in 2007 and the death of University of Connecticut's Jasper Howard this year, providing a safe learning environment seems as if it's becoming a harder task to uphold.

In the past few weeks, the University has reported a sexual occurrence in Lyon Tower and a robbery outside Arnold Hall.

No one can get past what happened to Ryan Diviney at the Willey Street Dairy Mart a couple weekends ago.

These events follow a stabbing on Grant Avenue and shots fired that went into the side of Summit Hall.

These crimes make me wary of walking the streets late at night.

In addition, the U.S. Department of Education reported University police violated the Clery Act in the past.

According to The Charleston Gazette, the University is looking at fines for mislabeling, under-reporting and failing to include crimes in the 2001 and 2002 Clery Reports.

The University police do their job.

They have systems such as the emergency telephones placed around campus as well as the emergency text alerts we receive when a crime is reported.

However, what we've seen is that the telephones are mainly subject to false reports, and the text alerts can be unreliable.

Getting students to be more proactive with their safety should take precedence over possession of a controlled substance or underage consumption citations, which is what usually what fills up the University incident reports.

On the University police Web site I found posters with proactive information, such as a checklist for violence prevention, that I've never seen before on campus.

This is unfathomable.

The Morgantown Police Department, as well as friends and family members, have been urging those who witnessed the altercation on Willey Street that put Ryan Diviney in the Intensive Care Unit at Ruby Memorial Hospital to come forward with information.

Though I'm not privy to this situation, nothing has come out regarding anyone with information about the thugs who sought to beat a young man within inches of his death.

The response should have been overwhelming.

According to The Dominion Post, there is video of several witnesses during the fight that broke out near the Dairy Mart.

Specifically, two females fled the scene along with other unknown bystanders.

Why haven't these witnesses come forward?

If you have and the public just hasn't been made aware, I commend your efforts in seeking a safer community for all of us.

If you haven't: How you can live with yourself?

How you can get up every morning knowing that Ryan is lying in a hospital bed fighting for his life?

His life and his family's lives are put on hold while his assailants walk the streets.

Be responsible.

Look after your belongings. Lock your doors.

If you see someone being pummeled by a large group of guys, call the police.

If you witness a violent crime, volunteer information.

We need to depend on ourselves to take preventative steps and keep this campus and community safer for everyone.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

18 comments

Ken Diviney (Ryan's Dad)
Wed Dec 9 2009 02:06
I have been watching the discussion on this well written article since it was published. I've had to patiently wait, as the debate unfolded. Really, all sides make valid points. The good news is, soon most of the "what if's" will be known by more than my family and the police. I simply cannot wait for it to be reported, which will be any day now.

Ryan & 2 friends were simply going to get a late night snack (some sort of pizza roll that is popular) with two friends. Ryan is not a violent individual. He has always been quite skilled (& prided himself) in being able to use words to diffuse situations. This is exactly why he wanted to become a lawyer; to settle conflict in a peaceful, fair manner. He believes in the rights of individuals and the right to be represented. By the way, the altercation started over a debated somehow related to the world series teams. Something guys of sane mind love to debate all the time (& Ryan is a sports junkie, so I can certainly see him wanting to talk about it).

Well, his words weren't enough this time. He was surrounded by half-a-dozen degenerates that were out looking for a fight. Ryan is a strong, tall (6'1"), healthy man. Very fit & athletic (he was a standout baseball & football player; in fact, he is the only player in his school's 40 year history, with 1,800 students enrolled, to make all-district 3 consecutive times). Certainly not the type of person someone would find venerable; unless, of course the odds were against him (7:1, in this case). Ryan, driven only by the urge to grab a snack with friends (by the way, Ryan was not intoxicated as evidenced by the toxicology reports from when they pumped his stomach to prevent him from throwing up into his lungs when they ventilator was forced down his throat), was somehow targeted. He was blind-sided with a punch to the jaw that knocked him to the ground where his head hit a raised, metal grate. He was, in effect, sucker punched without even the chance to put his hands up to block the punch. He was immediately knocked-out. While lying there, blood pouring from his ear & head, he was repeatedly kicked in the head. His jaw was broken, his skull was cracked, his brain was damaged. I ask anyone to give one possible scenerio where these thugs (yes, they can now be undeniably called "thugs") can claim self-defense. Even while he clung to life, he was beaten senseless.

The Morgantown police have done a wonderful job. Not only did they save his life on the scene, they solved the case, and you will be seeing reports of the arrests before long. My deepest gratitude goes out to Officer Smith and Detective Dalton for their relentless efforts. Witnesses came forward. It was hard to keep quiet, but everything was being handled correctly. It was in the best interest of the investigation to not share some information.

Now, these criminals must face justice and answer to the State of West Virginia for Malicious Wounding; a felony carrying 2 - 10 years in state prison. The criminals have to answer to Ryan & my family. They have many obligations they are now accountable, & I intend to see the fulfill each & every one.

So, what does this all mean? Ryan is still in a coma one month later. He fights for his life even to this day. Our family life, as we knew it, came to a shattering end. Now, no one is better off. People will be going to prison. People will be paying medical bills (possibly forever). WVU got press that will impact enrollment. Families were crushed. A young man, with so much promise, might never wake. The legal system will be burdened.

Still, in all this grief, my heart is touched by the overwhelming support of the WVU community. You should be so proud of your university. They students, staff, professors, president, police, & administration have gone beyond anything I could have ever expected. I can now see why Ryan loves being a Mountaineer. He poured his heart & soul into WVU. His pride for the school was infectious. All summer, he rode with the roof down in the jeep playing "Take Me Home Country Roads" at full volume. His tire cover is a flying WV. His floor mats are WV. He has a huge decal on his bedroom window that proclaims "Almost Heaven, West Virginia". He is a Mountaineer to the core.

So, in Ryan's honor: LET'S GO... MOUNTAINEERS!

Christopher Prigge
Wed Dec 2 2009 07:30
The Morgantown Police are incompetent and will never find these punks. Last year I was assaulted by 6 guys and it was caught on camera. I was transported by ambulance to the hospital with a broken nose and several deep lacerations. The guys said I started it and made up all these lies which the video footage showed to be false. Those guys walked and the police never took names of my witnesses and told me I would be arrested if I wanted to press charges on them. The officer tried to stop me from pressing charges and told me they always arrest both sides and let the judge sort it out. Till this day nothing has been done
Jen
Thu Nov 19 2009 14:09
Two weeks before this incident another man was beaten in the same area. He was visiting WVU and was walking back to the place he was staying. This was at night and someone called 911. He was in the hospital with fractures to his face. How come this didn't make the papers/news? Could these two cases be related? Does anyone have information on this incident? PLEASE COME FORWARD!
Mr. T
Thu Nov 19 2009 08:13
As it is written:

There is no one righteous, not even one;
there is no one who understands,
no one who seeks God.
All have turned away,
they have together become worthless;
there is no one who does good,
not even one."
"Their throats are open graves;
their tongues practice deceit."
"The poison of vipers is on their lips."
"Their mouths are full of cursing and bitterness."
"Their feet are swift to shed blood;
ruin and misery mark their ways,
and the way of peace they do not know."
"There is no fear of God before their eyes."
Now we know that whatever the law says, it says to those who are under the law, so that every mouth may be silenced and the whole world held accountable to God.
Therefore no one will be declared righteous in his sight by observing the law; rather, through the law we become conscious of sin.

Romans 3

Mr. T will not hid his identity from those responsible for Ryan's situation nor from those who defend their actions

Your name
Thu Nov 19 2009 01:27
In many if not all cases like this people do things in t their lives that most there friends and family are unaware. They make their loved seem as though they are the only victim. Do not get me wrong what happened was horrid, but maybe he was involved in something that has not surfaced yet, during this entire investigation. Maybe Mr. Diviney and his friends were in fact instigating a rise out of another group or young men or women, maybe they were doing the exact same thing that is other group that some may label as "thugs" did. Another thing, just because it said they was a group of 5-7 others does not mean that this group of 5-7 others ALL took place in this beat down of the young man. For a second before casting stones maybe just maybe HE was the one intimidating or even saying somehting to these supposed girls that were with these other guys. We do not know. The only people that know what happened are Mr. Diviney who unfortunately is un able to tell what happened, his friends that were there, this other group and the Surveillance tape. So before calling this other group that did put this individual in the hospital a bunch of Monsters, how about we all sit back let the system do what our Founding Fathers put it in place to do which is to look at the ENTIRE evidence and determine guilt and innocence. Let this happen Before someone says something wrong and than the tides turn and the other side turns out to be the real monsters.

With that said let the facts develop and the presumption of innocence remain until more information comes out or until the surveillance tape is allowed to be viewed by the public to dissiminate what happened. I will leave you with a few sayings that many may have heard and yet forgotten where it be from parents, pastors, etc. " Let he whos is without sin cast the first stone," and Judge not, or you too will be judged."

We all aren't God or a higher power or a judge in the court of law, so lets not point the finger too soon.

Get well soon Ryan and my prayers are with you and your family

Morgantown Student
Wed Nov 18 2009 23:26
First of all, to all your people who live out there in a bubble, THE MORGANTOWN COPS AREN'T GOING TO GET ANYTHING DONE! No one knows what happened, or at least that is how it seems. The parents of this kid need to hire a PI and start questioning people, smashing heads, and kicking down doors. It has been what, like 2 weeks since this happened? These guys are out there, sadly, laughing it up. Get some initiative, and stop trusting your god damn government so much. I am a WVU student who lives on High St. Every day I see the Morgantown mutants that walk these streets, and I am disgusted. You don't see the cops doing anything! People get stabbed on grant, beat up left and right, killed on beechhurst (couple of years back), molested on the rail trail, BUT THANKFULLY, Morgantown’s finest are there to apprehend everyone. No, they are more interested in busting kids who sell weed and massively understating rapes, then actually patrolling and making a difference. Final words, I hope that Ryan pulls through, and don't EVER count on others (police. witnesses, etc.) to be there for you. The sad truth is this: wise up, watch your back, and carry.
stopandthink
Wed Nov 18 2009 19:04
Let me start by saying that this is a great, beautifully written article, Denita Jones. All who are very close to Ryan Diviney and his family really appreciated reading it and seeing it in the D.A. I commend you for getting the word out and encouraging people to come forward.

I understand that the people who did this must be very afraid to come forward, considering that Ryan Diviney's final outcome with all of this is still unknown. (Please, everyone keep praying for him!) However, what the people who did this need to understand is that they are out there walking on their own, talking on their own, eating on their own, and are able to wake up on their own. These are all things that Ryan has yet to be able to do since that Friday night. Living with the guilt that you did this to someone and the fear that the cops may be knocking on your door or waiting for you outside your friend's house at any moment is NOT really LIVING at all. This fear must be horrible, which leads me to believe that there is little room to call the people who did this innocent at all. No innocent man would put himself through that torture. So please people, understand that it really hurts the people who are close to this situation to hear you say that these guys are innocent, or that it is wrong for people like columnists or anyone else for that matter to express the fact that these people are absolutely in the wrong and NEED to come forward. All anyone wants is information and justice. It is hard when people sit there and make comments on such a delicate situation in such a cold way. Just think about it.

Thanks again to Denita Jones for writing this! It means a lot to a lot of good people!
And please, EVERYONE pray for Ryan to make a full recovery!!

Mr. T
Wed Nov 18 2009 13:53
A crime has been committed. This is an irrefutable fact.
Ryan is a victim of this crime. Another irrefutable fact.

If the involved persons are innocent, then why are they protecting each other to this level? Why do they not come forward? What are they afraid of?
Come on….think people.

I suggest that since they have not come forward after all of this time, they understand that they are in fact GUILTY at some level. Innocent persons do not run and hide from justice in numbers. Individually, yes. As a group...not likely.
Come on….think people.

Those involved and the witnesses bear responsibility for their actions, whether this attack was provoked or not. I have trouble believing that two college students and one high school students actually picked a fight with a group of seven young men.
Come on…..think people.

One could easily speculate that those involved have talked several times since the incident. Additionally it is reasonable to assume that they have reached a collective decision not to come forward, and most likely are exerting influence on those witnesses to this end. Else, someone would have come forward.

In the end, they will be held accountable for their actions by a higher authority then we have here on Earth. Between now and then, there is a great amount of grief and sorrow surrounding the Diviney incident and our thoughts and prayers go out to the family and friends of this fine family in their darkest hour of need.

I, for one will not hide my identity from this position.

Your name
Wed Nov 18 2009 13:25
I don't care if the perps were defending themselves, (and really how could they have felt threatened when there were so many of them against so few). But lets say they did feel theatened, why don't they come forward and tell their story??? Why won't they explain what happened and let the family have some answers? Is it BECAUSE THEY ARE COWARDS!!!??? And that is why they act as a mob!!!???
Your name
Wed Nov 18 2009 13:24
I don't care if the perps were defending themselves, (and really how could they have felt threatened when there were so many of them against so few). But lets say they did feel theatened, why don't they come forward and tell their story??? Why won't they explain what happened and let the family have some answers? Is it BECAUSE THEY ARE COWARDS!!!??? And that is why they act as a mob!!!???
Your name
Wed Nov 18 2009 13:24
I don't care if the perps were defending themselves, (and really how could they have felt threatened when there were so many of them against so few). But lets say they did feel theatened, why don't they come forward and tell their story??? Why won't they explain what happened and let the family have some answers? Is it BECAUSE THEY ARE COWARDS!!!??? And that is why they act as a mob!!!???
Panacea
Tue Nov 17 2009 18:29
These problems come with a downtown campus that blurs the line between civilian and student life. .Weekly on High Street I see incidents instigated by buffoons. The party culture here is too dominating. Stuffing 30,000 students on a suffocating campus with thin academic requirements breeds these problems. Lower the acceptance rate of the university about 10% to keep out the riff-raff, and although these problems won't go away, they will decline. If we shaved off just 5k of lowest scoring students we'd have more space and a better academic culture.
Your name
Tue Nov 17 2009 16:44
Lets split hairs. None of you, including myself, know what went down, Did Ryan or the other "Thugs", which include the commrades with Ryan,start this dilema? Defending one self legally is legal. Who started the fight? If Ryan instigated the brohaha, then God forbid. But lets get to the root of the problem....young men today have no remorse. Single families, latchkey kids and lack of disipiline have created a bunch of monsters in this society, Drugs, gangs and taggers are the norm, I pray. and I do it often, thay Ryan recovers completely. But, the REALITY of the situation is that only 5-7 people actually know the truth. STOP THE SPECULATION. Ryan is devestatingly injured, but PLEASE..wait for the police to dissimiate the facts before passing judgement. 99.999% of WVU students don't know the facts. LET DUE PROCESS TAKE IT COURSE!
Thuglyfe
Tue Nov 17 2009 15:39
"How can you make a blanket statement that the perps were "Thugs". Were the individuals threatened before defending themselves? "

Yes....because pummeling someone into a coma when you outnumber them by a 2:1 ratio is, by definition of the very term, self-defense.

Your name
Tue Nov 17 2009 14:54
OK. What happened was more than horiffic. But can you say without any question that mitigating circumstances aren't in play here? What I ask is to let the police do their job, quit with this "Lynch Mob" mentality and when the appropriate time comes, report the facts of the story, reguardless of what light it may shed on any of the participants. I will say again, EVERYONE is innocent until proven guilty. The fact that Ryan is in such dire condition is unspeakable. But who in the world are you saying that "a group of 5-7 people are still walking your streets without feeling in moral obligation to come forward. " Who says these people aren't struggling with the moral dilema that is at hand? Bottom line is...this is a police matter. Let them handle it.
Your name
Tue Nov 17 2009 13:37
Ryan has been unconscious for 10 days now. One of the other kids has a broken jaw. Yeah, feel free to use the word thug. Ms. Jones. This family is in a huge amount of pain. If they had been threatened, then they would have been standing right there waiting for the police to file their own report. At this point, they don't know what Ryan's mental situation will EVER be. I think it is frightening that a group of 5-7 people are still walking your streets without feeling in moral obligation to come forward. I don't understand why the media in general isn't making a bigger deal out of finding these people that have changed lives FOREVER. I am pleased that Ms. Jones had the courage to right an article that expresses the same outrage that almost 3000 supporters on a facebook webpage feel.
Your name
Tue Nov 17 2009 13:03
Hold it one minute Ms. Jones. How can you make a blanket statement that the perps were "Thugs". Were the individuals threatened before defending themselves? You straight up admit that your not "privy to the situation" so why don't you do a little more investigation into this matter. Guess what? The police HAVE intervewed several of the "fleeing witnesses". How bout that. This is a horrible situation that needs to be handled in the justice system. Plus, doesn't our justice system give the presumption of innocense to all accused? Do you PERSONALLY know ALL the facts in the case? How about doing some more research before you condemn all, including witnesses WHO HAVE ALREADY SPOKE TO THE POLICE!
Your name
Tue Nov 17 2009 09:32
I also ask...HOW CAN ANYONE WHO WITNESSED RYAN DIVINEYS BEATING NOT COME FORWARD.
This could be your brother, friend or father one day. You would want someone to be held responsible.
You will live with the memory of what you saw FOREVER. At least feel somewhat good knowing that you
came forward to help capture these criminals. Go to the police and tell what you saw.






log out